59th Texas Tech University Comparative Literature Symposium, “Epic Fail”

Lubbock, TX, April 16–17, 2027

Submission deadline: December 20, 2026.

The idea of the “epic” conjugates grandiose scale and ambitious scope with spectacular achievement and lasting impact: epics are, almost by definition, success stories. Yet the epic is, counterintuitively but systematically, unthinkable without failure. The contours of every triumphal narrative are traced in defeat, shame, anxiety, suffering, loss, and grief. The experience of victimized or excluded “losers”—casualties of the foundation of culture, the spread of empire, the march of progress, or the self-actualization of the heroic individual—glosses victors’ (hi)stories, while the sacrifices made by the “winners” inscribe the affects of failure at the heart of the epic project.

As a literary form or orientation, too, both traditional epic and its diverse modern and global transformations are haunted by the risks attending extravagant aspirations. The famously unfinished monuments that dot various canons, from Gilgamesh, Statius’ Achilleid, and Ronsard’s Franciade to Pound’s Cantos and Musil’s Man Without Qualities or Frampton’s Magellan and Jodorowsky’s Dune, testify to the difficulty of bringing such endeavors to completion. Less literally, the imperfection or incompleteness that marks any ideology’s narrative instantiation works against the totalizing drive often associated with epic thinking and writing. Failure in the epic, then, is bound up with the failure of the epic—and that failure may well be a good thing for art. Modernist avant-gardes and their postmodern inheritors in experimental literature, cinema, and the visual arts across Europe, the Americas, and the Global South have self-consciously staged and celebrated fragmentation, imperfection, and incompleteness in contrast to closed structures limited by their very flawlessness (etymologically, the “perfect” is what is finished, done all the way through to the end). The aesthetics of non-fulfillment connects with philosophical discourses that abandon the epic project of systematicity to privilege notions of mobility, multiplicity, and contingency.

The mainstream American contemporary ethos of “success,” however, makes failure a dirty word, an embarrassment to be avoided or repressed at all costs. The syntagm “epic fail” emerges from early-2000s internet culture to simultaneously stigmatize, spectacularize, and trivialize personal inadequacies and public fiascos: the “epic fail” is a laughingstock, a punchline, a meme, something to be consumed and enjoyed, but only with a heavy seasoning of irony. Perhaps not coincidentally, these are the same conditions under which a postmodernity skeptical of grand narratives relates to epic discourse, and especially to proliferating public claims to sweeping, unmitigated success on various fronts. Yet rarely has it been more urgently necessary to think seriously about both failure and the fate of large-scale, ideologically charged storytelling—and, relatedly, about the ethics and politics of how we imagine and narrate disaster and collapse—than it is today, as the once-unassailable paradigms securing social and global orders falter while doomsaying narratives about imminent catastrophe in various domains, told from perspectives across the political spectrum, call us to immediate action only to become mired in controversy and contestation.

In the comparatist spirit of interdisciplinary inquiry, this conference invites participants to explore the relationships between failure and the epic, broadly conceived, in literature, cinema, performance, art, philosophy, history, anthropology, and sociology across areas, eras, traditions, and languages. Questions and topics might include, but are not limited to, the following:

  • Where is failure located in epic traditions and texts, and what are its functions in relation to the ideological and aesthetic stakes of epic storytelling?
  • What are the ethical and political stakes or challenges involved in representing and interpreting failure? How do artists and texts deal with them?
  • How and to what ends are epic narratives created, appropriated, and resisted in colonial, decolonial, post-colonial, and diasporic contexts?
  • What can we learn from examples of failed artistic and intellectual epic projects?
  • What does a politics of failure look like? Where is failure operational in the political landscape and its discourses? How do literature and critical theory reflect (on) it?
  • How do discourses of impending catastrophe in various domains (climate, ecology, technology, global health, morality, cultural identity, democracy, etc.) function poetically, politically, and philosophically?
  • What are the values of radical negativity and pessimism?
  • How can failure become a socio-political strategy, especially for minoritized communities?
  • Can failure be optimistic?
  • What is the place of failure in revolutionary or utopian thought and art?
  • How do (epic) narratives and texts fail? To do what? Why? With what consequences?
  • What aesthetic and philosophical potential can be found in staged or foregrounded incompleteness, imperfection, and fragmentation?
  • How do questions of scale impact on literary, historiographical, and philosophical representations of failure, ideological narratives, and the critical interpretation of both?

Please submit abstracts for 20-minute in-person presentations (200-250 words), along with a short bio/CV (100 words), to lucas.wood@ttu.edu by December 20, 2026.

Leave a Reply